1. Quick answer
GST treatment in a franchise or distribution network depends first on what each party actually supplies. A dealer buying goods and reselling them on its own account is different from an agent earning commission. A volume discount is different from payment for advertising services. A franchise fee is different from the sale of franchisee inventory. The contract, invoice flow, ownership/control of goods, consideration and actual conduct must be mapped together.
Identify business model→Map supplies→Separate discounts / services→Value + POS→Invoice + ITC + reconciliation
Core principle: “dealer”, “distributor”, “channel partner” or “franchisee” are commercial labels. GST classification follows the actual legal and commercial arrangement.
2. Legal framework
| Provision / source | Practical relevance |
|---|---|
| Section 7 | Determines supplies of goods/services and special deemed-supply situations. |
| Schedule I | Relevant to specified supplies between related persons/distinct persons even without consideration. |
| Section 8 | Composite and mixed supply analysis for bundled franchise/support packages. |
| Section 15 | Transaction value, related-person valuation and treatment of discounts. |
| Section 16 | ITC eligibility on franchise fees, software, advertising, services and purchases. |
| Section 17 | ITC restrictions and apportionment. |
| Section 31 | Tax-invoice requirements. |
| Section 34 | Credit/debit note mechanism for post-supply price adjustments where applicable. |
| Section 13 | Time of supply for services, including recurring franchise/support/commission services. |
| Section 12 | Place of supply for domestic goods and services. |
| Section 13(8)(b) | Relevant to intermediary services in cross-border situations; first determine whether the partner actually qualifies as an intermediary. |
| CBIC circular on discounts and promotional schemes | Clarifies treatment of discounts and promotional schemes, including discounts linked to purchase volumes and consideration for promotional services. |
| CBIC circular on voucher distribution through distributors, dealers and agents | Provides a useful current illustration of P2P versus agency models for voucher distribution through distributors/dealers/agents. |
3. P2P distribution vs agency: the first decision
| Feature | P2P distributor/reseller | Agent / commission model |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership/control | Distributor normally purchases and controls goods for resale. | Agent may sell on behalf of principal without owning the underlying supply. |
| Revenue | Trading margin / resale price difference. | Commission, fee or other agency consideration. |
| Customer invoice | Often distributor invoices customer. | Principal may invoice customer while agent earns commission. |
| Commercial risk | Typically bears inventory/price risk according to contract. | Risk may remain primarily with principal. |
| GST question | Analyse goods supply and any separate services. | Analyse agency/commission service and the underlying principal supply. |
Do not decide solely from the word “commission”. Read the agreement, invoice flow, ownership/control, stock risk and actual conduct.
4. Franchise fees, royalties and support
A franchise arrangement can contain several supplies: brand/IP rights, operating support, training, software, technical support, marketing support and product purchases. One annual amount may therefore require composite-supply analysis or careful contractual allocation.
Entry feeConsideration for obtaining franchise rights/support should be separately identified from inventory purchases.
RoyaltyTurnover-linked royalty is consideration for rights/services and should be analysed independently of product sales.
TrainingSeparate training fees are analysed as services; bundled training may form part of the broader franchise supply.
SoftwareMandatory POS/ERP/software fees need their own supply, POS and ITC analysis.
Technical supportSupport can be separate consideration or bundled with the franchise package.
Territory rightsExclusivity does not automatically determine the GST result; identify the actual right/service supplied.
5. Discounts, incentives and promotional payments
Discounts and incentives are a major source of GST disputes because the same commercial payment may be described as “rebate”, “incentive”, “support”, “margin”, “marketing contribution” or “service fee”. The underlying obligation matters.
| Payment pattern | Primary GST question |
|---|---|
| Discount established before/at supply | Check whether it can be excluded from transaction value under Section 15(3). |
| Post-supply discount under pre-existing agreement | Check statutory conditions and recipient ITC adjustment requirements. |
| Discount for specific advertising activity | May be consideration for a promotional service rather than a pure price reduction. |
| Volume incentive without reciprocal service | Analyse as commercial price adjustment where the legal conditions are satisfied. |
| Display/marketing payment | Where a specific service is supplied for consideration, analyse it as a service. |
| Year-end rebate | Reconcile agreement, target calculation, credit note and ITC treatment. |
CBIC CBIC circular on discounts and promotional schemes: it distinguishes discounts from payments made for identified promotional/marketing services. The documentation should make the commercial substance clear.
6. Dealer/distributor mechanics
InventoryMap when goods move, who owns them and who bears risk.
Credit notesLink price adjustments to original supplies and ITC treatment.
WarrantySeparate warranty obligations, parts, labour and reimbursement.
ReturnsDocument return of stock and tax adjustment.
FreightIdentify who contracts with transporter and whether freight is part of value or separate service.
Government chargesRegistration/road-tax/permit payments should be separated from dealer service fees where appropriate.
Channel-partner revenue map
Goods marginCommissionRoyaltyAdvertising supportWarrantySoftwareTraining
7. Commission and channel services
Commission may arise for sales agency, lead generation, referral, financing referrals, insurance distribution, extended-warranty sales, marketing or other channel services. Classify the actual service before determining place of supply.
Intermediary caution: not every distributor, reseller or channel partner is an intermediary. First test the statutory definition and the actual role. For cross-border transactions, this distinction can materially affect the place-of-supply analysis.
Questions
- Does the partner arrange or facilitate a supply between two other persons?
- Does the partner supply the underlying goods/services on its own account?
- Who owns the inventory?
- Who contracts with the end customer?
- Who bears commercial risk?
- What exactly does the partner promise to do?
- Is the payment linked to that activity?
8. Contracts and valuation
| Clause | Why finance should review it |
|---|---|
| Minimum purchase | May affect commercial pricing but does not automatically create a separate taxable supply. |
| Target incentive | Identify whether payment is discount or consideration for service. |
| Marketing obligation | Specific obligations can indicate a promotional service. |
| Exclusivity | May form part of franchise rights but does not itself determine agency. |
| Warranty reimbursement | Clarifies who supplies repair service and who bears warranty cost. |
| Termination fee | Need to distinguish compensation/forfeiture from consideration for a taxable activity. |
| Handling/convenience fee | Usually needs separate service/value analysis. |
9. Cross-border franchise and channel arrangements
International arrangements need a separate supply-by-supply analysis. A foreign franchisor's royalty/support fee to an Indian franchisee can involve import-of-service and reverse-charge questions. Conversely, commission received from an overseas principal requires a place-of-supply and export-of-service analysis.
Foreign royaltyAnalyse supplier location, recipient location, nature of service, POS and RCM.
Foreign technical supportMap the actual service and determine import-of-service treatment.
Indian export commissionDetermine whether the service satisfies all export-of-service conditions.
IntermediaryTest the statutory definition before applying intermediary POS rules.
Foreign distributorPrincipal-to-principal goods sale differs from agency service.
DocumentationAgreement, invoices, remittance evidence and role description should agree.
10. ITC
| Cost | ITC review |
|---|---|
| Franchise fee | Check business use, valid invoice and Section 17 restrictions. |
| Royalty/support | Review GST/RCM and Section 16 conditions. |
| Advertising service | Verify actual service and tax invoice. |
| Software/POS | Reconcile invoice to GSTR-2B and assess eligibility. |
| Training | Review business nexus and restrictions. |
| Dealer discount credit note | Track tax adjustment and corresponding recipient ITC implications. |
Do not use “appears in GSTR-2B” as the only ITC test. Portal data is evidence for reconciliation; legal eligibility still needs Section 16/17 and transaction-level review.
11. Returns, e-invoicing and reconciliation
Outward-side controls
- Reconcile manufacturer/principal sales with e-invoices, GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B.
- Track credit/debit notes against original invoices.
- Separate commission/service invoices from goods invoices.
- Document incentives and discounts with agreement and calculation.
Inward-side controls
- Dealer/distributor reconciles purchase register with GSTR-2B.
- Match GSTIN, invoice number, date, taxable value and tax.
- Review supplier credit notes and post-sale discounts.
- Maintain a separate incentive/commission reconciliation.
Contract→Invoice→Books→GSTR-1 / 2B→GSTR-3B→ITC / output review
12. Decision matrix
| Arrangement | Initial direction | Critical evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Independent reseller | Analyse principal-to-principal goods supplies. | Ownership, invoice and inventory risk. |
| Commission agent | Analyse agency service and POS. | Agency contract and commission basis. |
| Franchise entry fee | Analyse franchise/right/support service. | Franchise agreement and fee schedule. |
| Royalty | Analyse right/service consideration separately from goods. | Royalty clause and calculation. |
| Volume discount | Test Section 15(3). | Pre-existing agreement and target proof. |
| Marketing incentive | Determine discount vs promotional service. | Activity obligation and deliverables. |
| Warranty reimbursement | Identify actual repair/service relationship. | Warranty policy and reimbursement statement. |
| Foreign commission | Determine POS/export/intermediary status. | Cross-border agreement and actual role. |
13. Practical scenario library
133 practical scenarios cover franchise, dealership, distribution, agency, incentives, discounts, warranty, advertising, software, government reimbursements, cross-border arrangements, ITC and reconciliation.
| # | Situation | Facts | Review direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Franchise joining fee | Franchisor charges an upfront franchise entry fee | Identify the taxable service, place of supply, invoice and ITC treatment. |
| 2 | Annual franchise renewal | Franchisee pays recurring renewal fee | Analyse as consideration for continuing franchise/brand rights or services. |
| 3 | Territory fee | Distributor pays a fee for exclusive territory | Determine whether it is a separate right/service and apply place-of-supply and valuation rules. |
| 4 | Brand usage fee | Franchisee pays for use of brand/trade name | Separate brand/IP consideration from product sale and analyse the applicable supply. |
| 5 | Dealership appointment fee | Dealer pays appointment fee to manufacturer | Identify whether the fee is for dealership support, rights, training or another service. |
| 6 | Security deposit | Dealer gives refundable security to principal | Test whether it is genuinely refundable and whether it is consideration or security. |
| 7 | Non-refundable deposit | Dealer pays non-refundable amount on appointment | Analyse whether the amount represents consideration for a supply. |
| 8 | Minimum purchase commitment | Distributor must buy a minimum annual quantity | Do not automatically treat the commitment as a separate supply; analyse the actual commercial arrangement. |
| 9 | Shortfall payment | Distributor pays amount for missing annual target | Determine whether it is consideration for a service/right or compensation/adjustment, based on contract and facts. |
| 10 | Target incentive | Distributor receives incentive after reaching sales target | Review Section 15(3), contractual linkage and whether the incentive is consideration for a separate service. |
| 11 | Volume rebate | Dealer receives year-end volume rebate | Determine whether the discount was established in terms of an agreement before or at supply and whether ITC conditions for reduction are met. |
| 12 | Post-sale discount | Manufacturer grants discount after sale | Apply Section 15(3) conditions; distinguish true discounts from consideration for promotional services. |
| 13 | Promotional support | Distributor receives payment for promotional activities | If the distributor provides a service in return, analyse as taxable consideration rather than a simple discount. |
| 14 | Advertisement reimbursement | Principal reimburses dealer's local advertising | Identify whether dealer supplied advertising/marketing service to principal. |
| 15 | Co-operative advertising | Brand and dealer jointly fund advertising | Review who contracts with advertiser, who receives service and how reimbursement is structured. |
| 16 | Market development fund | Distributor receives market development support | Determine whether payment is a discount or consideration for identified promotional obligations. |
| 17 | Display incentive | Dealer receives payment for maintaining display standards | Where specific activity is performed for consideration, analyse as a service. |
| 18 | Sales incentive | Salesperson/dealer receives performance incentive | Identify recipient and whether payment is linked to an independent service or reduction in purchase price. |
| 19 | Commission model | Agent sells goods for commission | Distinguish principal-agent arrangement from principal-to-principal trading. |
| 20 | P2P distribution | Distributor purchases goods and resells on its own account | Trading margin is generally part of the distributor's commercial pricing; analyse each actual supply. |
| 21 | Agency distribution | Distributor sells on behalf of principal for commission | Commission/agency service needs its own GST analysis. |
| 22 | Consignment stock | Principal places stock with distributor without immediate sale | Determine when supply occurs and whether distributor acts as agent or independent buyer. |
| 23 | Sale-or-return | Dealer receives goods for sale or return | Review transfer of title/control, invoicing and time of supply. |
| 24 | Demo vehicle | Manufacturer gives dealer a vehicle for demonstration | Determine whether there is a supply, business use, capital-goods/ITC issue or later sale. |
| 25 | Demo equipment | Principal provides equipment for demonstration | Document ownership, duration, use and eventual disposal/sale. |
| 26 | Free promotional goods | Principal gives dealer free samples | Apply Section 17(5)(h) and business-promotion rules where relevant; do not assume ITC or GST treatment from “free” label. |
| 27 | Replacement stock | Defective goods replaced under warranty | Map original sale, replacement, credit note and warranty obligations. |
| 28 | Warranty reimbursement | Manufacturer reimburses dealer for warranty repairs | Determine whether dealer provides repair service to manufacturer or merely performs manufacturer's warranty obligation. |
| 29 | Warranty parts | Principal supplies parts free to dealer for warranty repairs | Track goods movement and service consideration separately. |
| 30 | Service labour reimbursement | Dealer receives labour reimbursement for warranty work | Analyse whether reimbursement is consideration for dealer's repair service. |
| 31 | Training support | Franchisor provides training to franchisee | Determine whether training is bundled into franchise fee or separately supplied. |
| 32 | Training fee | Franchisee pays separate training fee | Analyse taxable training service and ITC. |
| 33 | Software subscription | Franchisee pays for mandatory ERP/software | Separate software/licence/service consideration from franchise fee. |
| 34 | POS software fee | Dealer pays mandatory POS platform fee | Identify supplier, place of supply and tax invoice. |
| 35 | Royalty plus sales | Franchisee pays royalty based on turnover | Royalty is consideration for rights/services; analyse valuation and place of supply separately from product sales. |
| 36 | Royalty minimum guarantee | Franchisee pays minimum royalty regardless of sales | Determine contractual consideration and time of supply. |
| 37 | Franchise fee bundled with goods | Upfront fee is adjusted against future purchases | Map consideration and whether the adjustment affects transaction value. |
| 38 | Purchase discount for franchise fee | Principal gives product discount equal to franchise fee | Review contractual linkage and Section 15(3) treatment. |
| 39 | Dealer margin | Manufacturer sells to dealer at a discount | Normal commercial pricing does not by itself create a separate service by dealer. |
| 40 | Additional margin for promotion | Dealer receives extra margin for promotional obligations | If obligations are consideration for service, assess separately. |
| 41 | Credit note discount | Manufacturer issues GST credit note for volume discount | Check Section 15(3), agreement timing and recipient ITC reversal conditions. |
| 42 | Financial incentive without service | Principal pays incentive solely based on purchases | Determine whether it is a price adjustment rather than service consideration. |
| 43 | Financial incentive for identified activity | Principal pays for specific advertising or lead generation | Likely requires separate service analysis where a reciprocal obligation exists. |
| 44 | Lead generation fee | Dealer supplies customer leads to principal | Analyse as marketing/lead-generation service. |
| 45 | Referral commission | Partner refers customers for commission | Commission service is separately taxable subject to place-of-supply rules. |
| 46 | Channel partner commission | Technology company pays channel partner commission | Identify intermediary/agent characteristics and determine place of supply. |
| 47 | Intermediary issue | Partner arranges supply between principal and customer | Analyse Section 2(6) intermediary definition and the applicable place-of-supply rule. |
| 48 | Independent reseller | Reseller buys goods and resells independently | Do not treat every reseller as an intermediary. |
| 49 | Exclusive distributor | Distributor has exclusive territory | Exclusivity alone does not determine agency; examine ownership and contractual control. |
| 50 | Principal-owned stock | Distributor stores principal-owned stock | Assess whether storage/handling service exists separately from sales agency. |
| 51 | Warehouse fee | Principal pays distributor for storage | Separate warehousing service from distribution margin. |
| 52 | Logistics reimbursement | Distributor recovers freight cost from principal | Test whether freight is its own service cost or a pure-agent/contractual component. |
| 53 | Freight paid by distributor | Distributor pays transporter and recovers exact amount | Review contractual liability, transport service recipient and Rule 33 conditions. |
| 54 | Insurance reimbursement | Dealer recovers insurance premium | Separate statutory/third-party premium from any dealer service or bundled consideration. |
| 55 | Registration expense reimbursement | Dealer pays vehicle registration cost for customer | Determine whether dealer is pure agent and whether customer is liable to authority. |
| 56 | Road tax reimbursement | Dealer collects road tax from buyer | Separate statutory road tax from taxable dealer/service consideration. |
| 57 | Handling charge | Dealer charges vehicle handling fee | Analyse as dealer's own consideration where applicable. |
| 58 | Documentation fee | Dealer charges documentation fee | Identify actual service supplied and tax treatment. |
| 59 | Convenience fee | Dealer charges convenience fee for arranging registration | Separate taxable facilitation/service fee from statutory charge. |
| 60 | Finance referral commission | Dealer receives commission from financier | Separate financing/referral service from vehicle sale. |
| 61 | Insurance commission | Dealer receives commission from insurer | Analyse insurance distribution/agency service separately. |
| 62 | Banking partner incentive | Dealer receives incentive from lender | Determine service obligation and GST classification. |
| 63 | Extended warranty commission | Dealer receives commission for extended warranty sale | Analyse commission service and principal relationship. |
| 64 | Membership programme | Franchisee sells membership and shares revenue | Map each supply, consideration and contractual role. |
| 65 | Gift voucher distribution P2P | Distributor buys vouchers at discount and resells | Apply the voucher-specific legal framework and distinguish P2P trading from agency. |
| 66 | Voucher distribution agency | Distributor distributes vouchers for commission | Analyse agency/commission model separately from P2P trading. |
| 67 | Dealer-owned inventory | Dealer owns inventory before customer sale | Supports P2P model but actual contract and title/control should be reviewed. |
| 68 | Principal invoice to customer | Principal invoices end customer while dealer earns commission | Strong agency indicator; verify contractual role. |
| 69 | Dealer invoices customer | Dealer invoices customer in own name | Can support P2P/reseller model, but invoice flow alone is not conclusive. |
| 70 | Price protection | Principal compensates dealer when product price falls | Determine whether it is price adjustment or separate consideration. |
| 71 | Stock liquidation support | Principal pays dealer to clear old stock | Analyse whether payment adjusts purchase price or pays for a separate liquidation service. |
| 72 | Old stock return | Dealer returns unsold stock | Review original supply, credit note, return terms and tax adjustment. |
| 73 | Buyback arrangement | Principal buys back dealer stock | Map whether it is a new supply, return/cancellation or contractual buyback. |
| 74 | Damage allowance | Principal grants allowance for damaged stock | Determine whether allowance is discount/price adjustment or consideration for service. |
| 75 | Shrinkage recovery | Principal recovers inventory shortage from distributor | Analyse contract, compensation and supply characterization. |
| 76 | Penalty for late reporting | Principal charges dealer for reporting delay | Determine whether it is a contractual penalty/compensation rather than consideration for service. |
| 77 | Penalty for target failure | Principal charges target shortfall amount | Do not automatically classify as taxable service; analyse legal and contractual nature. |
| 78 | Termination fee | Franchisee pays termination amount | Assess whether it is compensation/forfeiture or consideration for a tolerating/other service, based on facts and applicable law. |
| 79 | Exit fee | Dealer pays exit fee on termination | Review contract and actual reason for payment. |
| 80 | Non-compete fee | Franchisee receives/ pays amount for non-compete obligation | Analyse separately under the applicable supply provisions and contract. |
| 81 | Franchise transfer fee | New franchisee pays transfer fee | Identify who supplies the transfer/approval service and who receives consideration. |
| 82 | Change-of-control fee | Principal charges fee for ownership change | Analyse as approval/administrative service if supplied for consideration. |
| 83 | Audit fee | Franchisor charges dealer for mandatory audit | Determine whether it is part of franchise support or separate audit service. |
| 84 | Compliance fee | Principal charges compliance platform fee | Identify technology/compliance service and tax treatment. |
| 85 | Mystery shopping fee | Dealer pays fee for mystery-shopping programme | Analyse service received and ITC eligibility. |
| 86 | Brand standards inspection | Franchisor conducts inspection and charges fee | Separate inspection service from franchise rights. |
| 87 | Technical support fee | Franchisee pays technical support fee | Taxable support service analysis. |
| 88 | Maintenance support | Principal provides maintenance under separate fee | Identify service and place of supply. |
| 89 | Spare parts sale | Principal sells spare parts to dealer | Normal goods-supply analysis, separate from support fees. |
| 90 | Parts discount | Principal gives spare-parts discount based on volume | Section 15(3) analysis and ITC adjustment conditions. |
| 91 | Service labour discount | Principal discounts service labour charges | Determine whether discount is linked to supply and documented under Section 15(3). |
| 92 | Free spare parts | Principal supplies free parts for warranty | Review ITC and documentation implications; “free” does not decide tax treatment. |
| 93 | Bundle of goods and services | Franchise fee includes goods, training and support | Identify whether bundled supply is composite/mixed and principal supply. |
| 94 | Mixed franchise package | Single price covers independent goods and services | Analyse mixed-supply rules if supplies are not naturally bundled. |
| 95 | Annual package | One annual fee covers brand, software, training and support | Determine the principal supply or separate supplies from contract. |
| 96 | Territory exclusivity plus support | Fee covers exclusive territory and ongoing support | Map rights and services included in consideration. |
| 97 | International franchise fee | Indian franchisee pays foreign franchisor | Analyse import of service, place of supply, recipient location and RCM. |
| 98 | Foreign technical support | Indian dealer receives technical support from overseas principal | Review import-of-service and RCM implications. |
| 99 | Foreign royalty | Indian franchisee pays royalty to overseas franchisor | Analyse import of service and RCM separately from domestic product purchases. |
| 100 | Export distributor commission | Indian principal pays commission to foreign distributor | Determine place of supply and export-of-service conditions; intermediary issues may be relevant. |
| 101 | Indian channel partner for export | Indian exporter pays commission to Indian channel partner | Domestic taxable service analysis; do not confuse with export supply merely because final goods are exported. |
| 102 | Cross-border lead generation | Foreign partner generates leads for Indian principal | Determine place of supply and intermediary/marketing classification. |
| 103 | Related distributor | Distributor is related to manufacturer | Review valuation and related-person provisions where applicable. |
| 104 | Distinct GSTIN dealer | Same legal entity has different GST registrations | Map supplies between distinct persons and determine valuation/reporting. |
| 105 | Stock transfer to branch | Goods move to another GSTIN under same PAN | Section 7/Schedule I and valuation provisions may apply. |
| 106 | Common advertising by group | One entity pays advertising and recovers from group dealers | Separate inter-company service and dealer promotion arrangements. |
| 107 | Franchisee reimbursement | Franchisee reimburses franchisor's legal fees | Test whether it is pure-agent disbursement or part of franchisor's own service cost. |
| 108 | Legal filing reimbursement | Dealer reimburses statutory filing fee | Rule 33 test and exact receipt evidence. |
| 109 | Government fee bundled with dealership | Dealership package includes licence/registration cost | Separate statutory payment from dealership service where possible. |
| 110 | Tax invoice missing | Distributor invoice does not contain required particulars | Resolve documentation before ITC claim. |
| 111 | Wrong GSTIN | Dealer's purchase invoice carries another GSTIN | Correct document before relying on ITC. |
| 112 | GSTR-2B mismatch | Dealer's purchase invoice is absent from GSTR-2B | Supplier follow-up and reconciliation required. |
| 113 | Credit note missing in books | Principal issues discount credit note | Reconcile credit note and ITC reversal where applicable. |
| 114 | Duplicate incentive | Same target incentive booked twice | Match agreement, calculation and credit note. |
| 115 | Period mismatch | Annual incentive booked in different period | Map agreement date, supply period and credit note. |
| 116 | E-invoice requirement | Distributor transaction crosses applicable e-invoicing threshold | Check supplier's e-invoice applicability and document compliance. |
| 117 | E-way bill | Goods move from principal to distributor | Check movement documentation, invoice/bill of supply and applicable e-way bill rules. |
| 118 | Place of supply goods | Dealer purchases goods across states | Determine POS based on goods movement and transaction facts. |
| 119 | Place of supply service | Franchisor supplies franchise/support service across states | Determine applicable Section 12/13 rule based on recipient/service type. |
| 120 | Intermediary POS | Channel partner arranges supply | Check Section 13(8)(b) where the transaction is an intermediary service and recipient is outside India. |
| 121 | Commission agent POS | Agent provides sales support | Classify actual service before choosing the place-of-supply rule. |
| 122 | Discount shown on invoice | Dealer receives discount at time of sale | Usually easier to evaluate under transaction-value/discount provisions if statutory conditions are met. |
| 123 | Discount after sale without agreement | Year-end discount is granted without prior linkage | Review whether it can reduce taxable value under Section 15(3). |
| 124 | Discount with prior agreement | Agreement sets volume discount before supply | Document agreement and calculate correctly. |
| 125 | Discount linked to service | Payment called discount but dealer must advertise brand | Potential service consideration; examine reciprocal obligations. |
| 126 | ITC on franchise fee | Franchisee claims ITC on GST paid on franchise fee | Review business use, documentation and Section 17 restrictions. |
| 127 | ITC on royalty | Franchisee claims ITC on taxable royalty/support service | Check Section 16, business use and applicable restrictions. |
| 128 | ITC on promotional service | Principal claims ITC on dealer marketing service | Verify actual service and tax invoice. |
| 129 | ITC on dealer discount | Dealer wants ITC after receiving credit note | Reconcile tax credit note and required reversal/adjustment. |
| 130 | Principal output reconciliation | Manufacturer reconciles sales to dealer | Match sales register, e-invoice, GSTR-1 and credit notes. |
| 131 | Distributor purchase reconciliation | Dealer reconciles purchases to GSTR-2B | Match GSTIN, invoice, date, taxable value and tax. |
| 132 | Incentive reconciliation | Finance reconciles annual incentives | Link target calculation, agreement, credit note/invoice and accounting entry. |
| 133 | Final channel audit | Tax team reviews entire network | Reconcile contracts, invoices, credit notes, incentives, commissions, stock movements and portal data. |
14. Audit checklist
Business-model review
Identify P2P vs agency
Map ownership/control of goods
Review inventory risk
Check customer invoicing flow
Identify every revenue stream
Review cross-border role
Discount/incentive review
Agreement timing checked
Target calculation supported
Service obligation identified
Credit note matched
ITC adjustment reviewed
Accounting entry reconciled
ITC/return review
Purchase register vs GSTR-2B
Sales vs GSTR-1
GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B
Credit notes reconciled
RCM reviewed
E-invoice/e-way bill controls
15. Frequently asked questions
Is a distributor an agent under GST?
Not automatically. A distributor buying and reselling goods on its own account can be different from an agent acting on behalf of a principal. The actual contract and conduct matter.
Is every dealer incentive taxable as a service?
No. Some incentives can be commercial price adjustments/discounts, while payments linked to identifiable promotional or other services may be consideration for those services.
Can post-sale discounts reduce taxable value?
Only where the statutory conditions for Section 15(3) are satisfied. The agreement, linkage to the supply and recipient ITC treatment should be documented.
Does a franchise fee include GST?
Where it represents consideration for a taxable franchise/right/support service, GST treatment should be determined from the actual supply and applicable provisions.
Is royalty different from product sales?
Yes. Royalty/right/support consideration should be mapped separately from the sale of inventory, even when both arise under the same commercial relationship.
Is every channel partner an intermediary?
No. First apply the statutory intermediary definition to the actual role. A principal-to-principal reseller is not automatically an intermediary.
Can franchisee claim ITC on franchise fee?
Potentially, where GST is legally charged and Section 16 conditions and Section 17 restrictions are satisfied.
Related GST resources
Continue with the GST library for discounts, royalty, e-commerce, reconciliation and ITC topics.
Browse all GST articles · GST Reconciliation Tool · GST Act Library · GST Compliance